• Make a Lasting Impression With Decadent Toffee Gifts and Favors

    Strengthen relationships and celebrate life’s special moments with personalized gourmet toffee.

Enrobed_Toffee_Lifestyle_ProductPage_2

Toffee Selections

All are made with pure, fresh, and the best ingredients.

Toffee_Treasure

Toffee Gift Boxes

The perfect gift solution for anyone on your list — customized with your business, branding, or event details.

artisan_gift_box_full

Artisan Gift Boxes

Celebrate with artisan gift boxes. Curated collections of fine artisan edibles; guaranteed to impress.

Best Selling Gifts

Gourmet Toffee —
Memorably Delicious

perfectly packaged sweet treats

The Toffee Store is passionate about creating gift experiences that leave a lasting impression. Proudly offering elite corporate gifts, memorable event favors, and artisan gift boxes, we start with our gourmet toffee, Made in Michigan. Available in six flavor varieties (all naturally gluten-free), we add your customization and our expert presentation skills. The end result is a perfectly packaged personalized gift, delivered to one or many, hassle-free.

Decadence and Excellence

3

3 Premium Ingredients

Rich and buttery with the perfect flaky crunch. We use pure cane sugar, dairy fresh butter, and quality vanilla to form the perfect base.

14

14 Years on The Market

Around 2009, Heidi Paterson decided to create an elegant take on a classic treat starting with the finest and freshest ingredients.

100%

Satisfaction Guarantee

Packaging is FDA approved. We’re registered with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

The Gifting Experts You Can Trust For

Exceptional Gifts and Effortless Shopping

Browse our sweet collection.

With eight varieties of decadent toffee and carefully curated artisan collections to accompany them, you’ll find something for everyone on your list, no matter the occasion. From single squares of toffee to individually wrapped overflowing artisan gift boxes, we’ll help you make a lasting impact.

We’ll handle every detail.

There’s no order too simple or complicated for us. We have every detail covered, from adding your custom logo or branding to elegant ribbon matching your event colors. Need to ship to multiple addresses? We can do that. Prefer to include a hand-addressed notecard and personalized message? It’d be our pleasure.

Happiness is 100% Guaranteed.

Each batch of toffee receives a 7-point inspection process from start to finish — we strive for excellence. No tissue paper or bubble wrap is spared to ensure your order endures shipping and arrives ready for an Instagram-worthy unboxing experience.

What Our Customers Are Saying

  • “I order consistently on a monthly basis and I am 100% satisfied with the products and the service! They go above and beyond to do what you need and have even helped us on last minute orders. Our clients have gone as far as reaching out to find out how they can get more!

    I would highly recommend for buisness gifts and even for weddings or showers!”

    – Nadia Luchtman –
  • I am incredibly pleased with the product and service provided by Heidi Paterson and The Toffee Store, and I have very high standards! Not only was the product delicious (and everyone loves it), but Heidi was also wonderfully detailed and highly responsive throughout the process. And all at very reasonable price. Not only will I patronize the Toffee Store in the future, but I have let my friends know about it as well.

    – Bill Chalmers, Owner Cartessa Real Estate Company –
  • “Absolutely delicious. The best toffee I’ve ever eaten.

    Contemplating ordering a second batch immediately because it’s taking everything in my power to keep from eating it all in one sitting”

    – Terrel Lastrapes –
  • “The individually packaged favors you provided for our baby shower delighted every recipient. The toffee was incredible. I had one guest call to say “don’t bother worrying about figuring out what to get me for Xmas, I want ten pounds of that toffee! Incomparable taste and texture in the toffee and a wonderful attention to detail. Thanks for providing a memorable gift for our guests.”

    – Suzanne O –
  • Heidi has helped me with delicious choices for our customers. Every thank you box we send the recipient is thrilled. Heidi also helped my wife with our daughter’s shower and wedding favors. The toffee is outstanding and so is the costumer service.

    – Jeff Starr –
  • The Toffee Store was so easy to work with for my Baby Shower and the people were incredibly friendly. They delivered the cutest guest favors for my Baby Shower and I received numerous comments that the Toffee was fantastic. I highly recommend them! 🙂

    – Ashley Quinn –
  • I have sent toffee to business people, and to family. I get such great feedback! I send a goodie box to family after staying with them. They were heading out of state a couple days later, and they said they were going to take it with them to share with their friends. I always get a phone call if sincere thanksfor this thank you gift.

    – Leslie Hocker –
  • I ordered toffee from The Toffee Store for my business. It arrived fresh and delicious! I shared it with customers and it was a big hit!

    – Tammi Gripton –
  • I love sending Toffee from Heidi as gifts! Everyone who has tried her toffee has been soo impressed. I love the variety she offers and the way everything always looks spectacular. Heidi truly is a gem and offers amazing customer service. You won’t be disappointed

    – Desiree with TeaSoulution –
  • I think this is the world’s best toffee, with no exaggeration! Crisp, sweet but not too sweet.. Every bite is pure deliciousness, and even though it does make great gifts for my business clients… it is really hard to think about sharing! lol. I just want to eat it all! My personal favorite is the Cherry Birthday toffee, but you really can’t go wrong with any of them.

    I was once present at a dinner celebration where we had The Toffee Store Toffee in front of our place settings as favors, and someone was feeling generous so they gave their box to the restaurant host when he came to ask how we were doing. He must have sampled it right away, because pretty soon all the staff was being extra nice to our table, and before we knew it we had all given our toffee away! The host said that he’s had toffee all over the world, and this was by far his favorite. It really is the perfect gift, even if you weren’t planning on sharing.

    – Johanna White –
  • In effort to provide my clients with a local artisan gift, I was referred to The Toffee Store. From the first call to the follow-up on the deliveries, Heidi made this experience one to remember for me and most importantly for my clients. She went above and beyond to create a gift that made my clients feel the appreciation that I have for them. In addition, I am hearing comments like “best toffee I’ve ever had” and “the presentation was gorgeous “. This experience is truly second to none. Thank You Heidi! Best, Kevin

    – Kevin Zezula –
  • I’m so glad to have connected The Toffee Store! Heidi makes it so easy. Your company logo, personalized note, and delicious toffee treats arrive in the classiest of packaging and just makes your customers feel special. If you want to take your gifting to the next level The Toffee Store is the option for you!

    – Patricia Muellen –
  • SHOP LOCAL!! SHOP THE TOFFEE STORE!! A huge shout out to The Toffee Store for making it easy to place a bulk holiday order for my clients! Heidi was very responsive and took the time to discuss options to enhance my order and overall experience. Heidi made it happen! 🙌🏻

    – Dawn Burdick –
  • Have worked with This company to provide business to business gifts for customers and referral partners. Their toffee is delicious and packaging is professionally done. I received great feedback!! Highly recommend partnering with The Toffee Store. Thanks Heidi!!

    – Michael Bashore –
  • Before I met Heidi I had no idea what I was missing out on! This toffee is the best! They make amazing gift baskets customized to your needs, great for business relationships!

    – Megan Brooks –
  • Heidi and her team are great. From initial concept and design, all the way to finished product. Great communication, and great end result for business gifts to give to my clients. 10/10 would highly recommend.

    – Ryley Austyn –

Heidi’s Mission

Bring Joy to Others Through Toffee.

The Toffee Shop was born from my personal mission to bring joy to others as an example of pure love. After a series of life events led me to a church holiday cookie sale where I thought, why not toffee? — I was encouraged by many to go into business.

Over a decade later, my team and I are honored to be part of your gift-giving. We start with gourmet toffee — often described as “the best toffee I’ve ever had!” — add your customization details and clean, crisp packaging that creates a perfectly presented gift, joy guaranteed.

Thank you to those who have trusted us to be part of their gift-giving and events – it is our pleasure to work with you. To those considering us for the first time, welcome.
It’s our sincere pleasure to be a part of your special moments.

heidi-signature

Blog