Toffee stack and ingredients wrapped in The Toffee Store branded gift ribbon
Be in the know!
Sign up here, and be the first to know about sales & exclusive, member only promos!

    Regarding COVID-19, your safety is our priority... Click HERE to read our safety procedures.

    Discover what makes
    our toffee the best.

    Experience Our Story

    Simple. Pure. Delicious.
    Crafted with just 3 ingredients

    All of our toffee is made in small batches with Michigan cane sugar, dairy fresh butter and pure vanilla. The Toffee Store proudly crafts, packages and ships our entire toffee line from our warehouse, located here in Michigan.

    Made in Michigan with pure love.

    Heidi Paterson - Owner The Toffee Store
    Meet Heidi
    The magic behind the toffee store.

    Around 2009, Heidi Paterson (owner of The Toffee Store) decided to create an elegant take on a classic treat starting with the finest and freshest ingredients. She ended up with a purely decadent confection.

    As a Type 1 Diabetic for 32 years, she wanted perfect toffee thickness, a balanced ratio of chocolate to toffee, and a satisfaction from quality, not quantity (for those carb counting...).

    Through trial and error, she created the perfect batch - having a delicate balance between a smooth buttery flavor and a gentle crunch that melts in your mouth after the first decadent bite.